Mystery Flavor
Mystery Flavor
Couldn't load pickup availability
THE WORKSHOP SERIES: Peek Behind the Curtain
What you're about to taste doesn't exist yet.
This is where recipes are born—messy, imperfect, gloriously alive. No labels. No polish. Just pure gelatiere obsession in a white cup.
We're inviting you into our kitchen at its most vulnerable. These are the batches we make at 2 AM when inspiration hits. The "what if we tried..." experiments. The flavors that might become legends, or might teach us exactly what not to do next time.
This is wabi-sabi in a cup—beauty in imperfection, honor in the attempt. Real artisans take risks. Sometimes we nail it. Sometimes we discover something completely unexpected. Always, we learn.
In traditional gelaterias, the gelato maker (gelatiere) would pull you aside and say, "Taste this, tell me what you think." That's this. You're not just a customer—you're part of the story, part of the discovery.
What to expect:
- Unlabeled white cups (we're saving costs, investing in ingredients instead)
- Flavors that might never appear again
- The thrill of tasting something before it has a name
- Imperfections that make it human
- Gelato made with passion, not perfection
Welcome to the workshop. Taste the adventure.
creamy and flavorful with interesting combos
I like the surprise factor of not knowing which flavor to get (but you can ask them for a clue via instagram dm). The gelato itself is very smooth and creamy with milk chocolate. Love the combination. It’s not too sweet, just the right amount of sweetness.
Love a little mystery with the gelato! Glad the surprise worked out. ‘Til your next mystery pick, Bettina!
I’ve tried at least 6 flavors from Crem Gelato and I love all of them!!! Glad I picked one mystery flavor in my last order!! It was soooo good! Thank you as always!!
Cherry French Vanilla is the absolute best! The balance of tanginess or the sour cherries and the creaminess of the vanilla base is divine, and can't wait for more!
love this mystery Cherry French Vanilla! would love more cherries in the mix for a better cherry to french vanilla ratio, and maybe a slightly sweeter french vanilla? this is great for any berry ice cream lover who wants the perfect balance of tang and vanilla creaminess that isn't too sweet. this mystery flavor made me even more excited for Amarena French Vanilla!
also enjoyed the Peanut Butter Stracietella (not pictured) — definitely a win for all the peanut butter lovers out there! may peanut butter chunks na, on peanut butter ice cream pa! the stracietella really sold it for me though, balanced everything out. a little more chocolate sauce drizzled inside would make it even better!
