Mystery Flavor
Mystery Flavor
Sold out for today
Couldn't load pickup availability
- Must Try
- Packaged in a Box
- Delivered Frozen
Flavor Description
THE WORKSHOP SERIES: Peek Behind the Curtain
What you're about to taste doesn't exist yet.
This is where recipes are born—messy, imperfect, gloriously alive. No labels. No polish. Just pure gelatiere obsession in a white cup.
We're inviting you into our kitchen at its most vulnerable. These are the batches we make at 2 AM when inspiration hits. The "what if we tried..." experiments. The flavors that might become legends, or might teach us exactly what not to do next time.
This is wabi-sabi in a cup—beauty in imperfection, honor in the attempt. Real artisans take risks. Sometimes we nail it. Sometimes we discover something completely unexpected. Always, we learn.
In traditional gelaterias, the gelato maker (gelatiere) would pull you aside and say, "Taste this, tell me what you think." That's this. You're not just a customer—you're part of the story, part of the discovery.
What to expect:
- Unlabeled white cups (we're saving costs, investing in ingredients instead)
- Flavors that might never appear again
- The thrill of tasting something before it has a name
- Imperfections that make it human
- Gelato made with passion, not perfection
Welcome to the workshop. Taste the adventure.
Finally got a chance to order the mystery flavored gelatos — vanilla bourbon and strawberry swirled with strawberry bits. Growing up, I was the type to order vanilla ice cream in every ice cream parlor to find the best. It’s been a while since I’ve had good vanilla ice cream/ gelato until I’ve tried the vanilla bourbon from Crem. The vanilla was fragrant and flavorful, with a subtle bourbon note. It makes me wonder, would a stronger bourbon flavor overpower the vanilla? Looking forward to it’s next versions!
The strawberry gelato on the other hand had a very pure and uncomplicated flavor. It was sweet with a slight tangy note, just how you would imagine a fresh strawberry would taste like. It’s a breath of fresh air compared to other store-bought gelatos, which could either be too milky or sometimes artificial tasting. The swirled bits definitely amped up the experience even more.
I’ve never really been a fan of mystery orders - whether it’s food or anything else - but man, you guys completely crushed my hesitation! We love all 4 flavors! 🖤
The one that stands out the most is STv2. My goodness, everything about that one is just perfect! Anyway, I can’t stop eating them all so I'm basically floating on cloud9 right now 😌
Crem, you captured my heart once again. Suddenly, the world is a better place 😊 Thank you!
creamy and flavorful with interesting combos
I like the surprise factor of not knowing which flavor to get (but you can ask them for a clue via instagram dm). The gelato itself is very smooth and creamy with milk chocolate. Love the combination. It’s not too sweet, just the right amount of sweetness.
Love a little mystery with the gelato! Glad the surprise worked out. ‘Til your next mystery pick, Bettina!
I’ve tried at least 6 flavors from Crem Gelato and I love all of them!!! Glad I picked one mystery flavor in my last order!! It was soooo good! Thank you as always!!
